Compatibility for Mathworks' and Xilinx tools integration (System Generator, Vivado, Support Package...)

Question

Martin Dendaluce 2014-12-8

0
链接

此问题的直接链接

https://ww2.mathworks.cn/matlabcentral/answers/165909-compatibility-for-mathworks-and-xilinx-tools-integration-system-generator-vivado-support-package

回答： nagendra 2017-3-14

After having read a comment by Yongfeng here, I'm more confused that I already was about the compatibility between the different Matlab and Xilinx tools and their versions.

I understand that it has to be clearly distinguished between two different ways to set up the integration:

Simulink + System Generator
Simulink + Target support package + Xilinx toolchain

Following Yongfeng's comment, System Generator wouldn't (1) be supported at all in R2014b?? Does this mean support has been removed, and that I need to use a previous Matlab? This seems â€œstrangeâ€. Or does it just mean that it won't work with Vivado 2014.3/.4? Looking here, the information seems contradictory.

Regarding to the second approach (2), according to R2014b release notes, Vivado is supported now (instead of ISE). So should this work with 2014.3/.4? After looking at the Vivado Release notes , I'm even more confused.

As far as I know System Generator (1) works with R2013b/2014a and 2014.2. And the previous setup with Target Support Package (2) (enabling PiL) was for ISE >14.4 and SDK >2013.4, right?

So: the specific question would be (as the previous setupsâ€™ compatibilities arenâ€™t really relevant): which are the latest usable versions for both mentioned setups?

A clarification of these points would be probably greatly appreciated by many people, and certainly by me. Unfortunately, I see several open issues related to HDL generation, IP cores and Vivado integration in the forums.

Best regards and thanks in advance.

Martin

1 个评论
显示 -1更早的评论隐藏 -1更早的评论

Martin Dendaluce 2014-12-8

As an additionnal comment, because although unfortunately I can't test it yet, I'm very interested in these workflows: the current alternative approach I will try to evaluate is to directly use Vivado HLS to translate generated C code into (V)HDL/Verilog. I see that this could even be integrated into Simulink by importing the output of Vivado HLS to a System Generator block. Furthermore, I'm also very interested in ways of setting up a PiL simulation with the Zynq and C code Synthesized to the FPGA, but I think that should probably be treated in a separate thread.

请先登录，再进行评论。

请先登录，再回答此问题。

Answer 1

Eric Cigan 2014-12-31

0
链接

此回答的直接链接

https://ww2.mathworks.cn/matlabcentral/answers/165909-compatibility-for-mathworks-and-xilinx-tools-integration-system-generator-vivado-support-package#answer_163750

Please note that in HDL Coder R2014b, both Xilinx ISE and Vivado are supported as downstream tools. I understand that Yongfeng was trying to distinguish between "classic" System Generator and Vivado System Generator, which is the version that isn't supported with subsystems in HDL Coder R2014b.