TriScatteredInterp doesn't extrapolate outside scattered data points

Question

0 个投票

hello everybody

I wonder why Mathworks considers TriScatteredInterp(x,y,z) as an extrapolation function while it only interpolates inside the area defined by "x,y" scattered points and it doesn't calculate outside that area.

http://www.mathworks.com/help/matlab/math/scattered-data-extrapolation.html

Am I doing something wrong, here is the code:

pos = [ 401.5   387.5   659.5    523.5   349.0   509.5;...
        304.0   305.0   405.5    205.0   483.5   229.5];
z1 = rand(1,6);
F1 = TriScatteredInterp(pos(1,:)',pos(2,:)',z1');
gx = 300:5:700;
gy = 200:5:500;
[qx,qy] = meshgrid(gx,gy);
z_1 = F1(qx,qy);

0 个评论
显示 -2更早的评论隐藏 -2更早的评论

请先登录，再进行评论。

请先登录，再回答此问题。

Follow Question

Answer 1

John D'Errico 2015-11-16

编辑：John D'Errico 2015-11-16

在 MATLAB Online 中打开

0 个投票

These tools use a triangulation of your data. They only are able to interpolate if your data is inside one of the triangles. And since a delaunay triangulation only extends out to the convex hull of your data, they do not extrapolate. Anyway, extrapolation is dangerous business.

Note that scatteredInterpolant can apparently extrapolate linearly based on the gradients at the edges, but that extrapolation will be poor in general. Do not trust it for far outside of your data. If you do not have the current release, then TriScatteredInterp does not support extrapolation at all.

Here is the help for scatteredInterpolant for extrapolation. Note that TriScatteredInterp never claims to extrapolate that I see anywhere in the help.

     F = scatteredInterpolant (..., METHOD, EXTRAPOLATIONMETHOD) supports the 
     selection of an extrapolation method to be used outside the convex hull.
     Where EXTRAPOLATIONMETHOD is one of the following: 
            'nearest' - Evaluates to the value of the nearest neighbor on the 
                        boundary (default for METHOD ='nearest')
            'linear'  - Performs linear extrapolation based on boundary gradients 
                        (default for METHOD = 'linear' and METHOD='natural')
            'none'    - Queries outside the convex hull will return NaN

1 个评论
显示 -1更早的评论隐藏 -1更早的评论

Abdelmoumen Bacetti 2015-11-16

Ohh, actually i won't trust any extrapolation unless I can cross validate it.

All I want, is to have values everywhere over my grid, and only the part inside the hull interests me.

Thanks anyway, and I guess i should use the trial version of R2015 to see it working.

请先登录，再进行评论。

Answer 2

Walter Roberson 2015-11-16

1 个投票

The link you posted refers only to scatteredInterpolant(), not to TriScatteredInterp() . TriScatteredInterp() is still present in MATLAB but the recommendation is to replace it with calls to scatteredInterpolant()