Why isn't my nested if statement not working

Question

Renae Duperron 2017-2-5

0
链接

此问题的直接链接

https://ww2.mathworks.cn/matlabcentral/answers/323499-why-isn-t-my-nested-if-statement-not-working

编辑： Sebastian 2017-2-6

Hi I'm very new to matlab and I'm trying to use if statements to solve for the mass moment of inertia but it only seems to work for the first if statement and I'm not sure why.

%This Program inputs direction, shape, and dimensions and output the moment
%of inertia
S  = input('Enter shape 1 Sphere 2 Circular disk 3 Cylinder 4 thin Ring: ');
a = input('Please enter specified axis 1x,2y or 3z: ');
m  = input('Please enter mass: ');
if S==1 && a==1 || a==2 || a==3
ds = input('Please enter dimensions r: ');
I1 = 2/5*m*ds^2;
elseif S==2 && a==1||a==2
dc = input('Please enter dimensions r: ');
I2 = 1/4*m*dc^2;
elseif S==2 && a==3
dc = input('Please enter dimensions r: ');
I3 = 1/2*m*dc^2;
elseif S==3 && a==1|| a==2
dcy = input('Please enter dimensions[r h]: '); 
I4 = m./12*(3.*(dcy(1,1))^2 + dcy(1,2)^2);  
elseif S==3 && a==3
dcy = input('Please enter dimensions r: ');
I5 = 1/2*m*dcy^2; 
elseif S==4 && a==1 || a==2 || a==3
dt = input('Please enter dimensions: ');   
I6 = m*dt^2;
end

0 个评论
显示 -2更早的评论隐藏 -2更早的评论

请先登录，再进行评论。

请先登录，再回答此问题。

Answer 1

Sebastian 2017-2-6

0
链接

此回答的直接链接

https://ww2.mathworks.cn/matlabcentral/answers/323499-why-isn-t-my-nested-if-statement-not-working#answer_253453

编辑：Sebastian 2017-2-6

在 MATLAB Online 中打开

I did not check the entire code but it looks like you got your conditions wrong because it always enters the first if for one simple reason. Let's assume that S = 3 (circular disk) and a = 2 (y), which means the program should enter the third elseif but it enters if instead. The conditions are being evaluated from left to right so it is all about the order of operations:

    if S == 1 && a == 1 || a == 2 || a == 3
    S == 1 evaluates to false
    false && a == 1 evaluates to false
    false || a == 2 evaluates to true
    true || a == 3 evaluates to true

Whatever you do your program will enter if because the entire statement will always evaluate to true. That is why you should bracket the conditions like this and then it works the way it is supposed to:

if S == 1 && (a == 1 || a == 2 || a == 3)
elseif S == 2 && (a == 1 || a ==2 )
elseif S == 2 && a == 3
elseif S == 3 && (a == 1 || a == 2)
elseif S == 3 && a == 3
elseif S == 4 && (a == 1 || a == 2 || a == 3)