Using chi2gof to test two distributions

16 次查看（过去 30 天）
Allie
Allie 2019-2-6
编辑： Sim 2024-8-14
I want to use the chi2gof to test if two distributions come from a common distribution (null hypothesis) or if they do not come from a common distribution (alternative hypothesis). I have binned observational data (x), binned model data (y), and the bin edges (bins). Both the observational and model data are counts per bin.
x= [41 22 11 10 9 5 2 3 2]
y= [38.052 24.2655 15.4665 9.8595 6.2895 4.011 2.562 1.6275 2.8665]
bins=[0:9:81]
Because the data is already binned and because I'm testing x against y, I used the following code
[h,p,stat]=chi2gof(x,'Edges',bins,'Expected',y)
Manual calculation of the chi2 test statistic results in 4.6861 with a probablity of p=.7905. The above function however, produces a very different result. The resulting stats show different bin edges than designated, the ovserved counts per bin do not match x, the chi2 test statistic is ~87, and p<0.001. Could someone please explain why I'm getting such dramatically different results?

请先登录，再回答此问题。

采纳的回答

Jeff Miller
Jeff Miller 2019-2-7
Sorry, the x's really do have to be the data values. Try this:
bins=[0:9:81]
xvals = bins(1:end-1)+4.5; % Here are some fake data values that belong in each bin.
xcounts= [41 22 11 10 9 5 2 3 2] % These are the counts of the data values in each bin.
y= [38.052 24.2655 15.4665 9.8595 6.2895 4.011 2.562 1.6275 2.8665];
[h,p,stat]=chi2gof(xvals,'Edges',bins,'Expected',y,'Frequency',xcounts,'EMin',1)
This will give you your 4.68. By default, chi2gof groups small bins (less than 5) together, and 'EMin' tells it not to do that.

更多回答（2 个）

Jeff Miller
Jeff Miller 2019-2-6
It looks like chi2gof expects the values in x to be the actual, original scores, not the bin counts. Try adding 'Frequency',x to the parameter list.
  1 个评论
Allie
Allie 2019-2-7
编辑：Allie 2019-2-7
This did not work. The stat output is below. As you can see, it changed the edges and expected values from what I originally input and the chi2stat became even bigger.
stat =
chi2stat: 234.4383
df: 5
edges: [0 9 18 27 36 45 81]
O: [12 30 22 0 41 0]
E: [38.0520 24.2655 15.4665 9.8595 6.2895 11.0670]

请先登录，再进行评论。

Sim
Sim 2024-8-14
编辑：Sim 2024-8-14
Shouldn't you use the two-sample chi-square test?
The CHI2TEST2 Version 1.0.0.0 (2.44 KB) function by James Meldrum performs the two-sample chi-square test.
The Chi-squared test needs binned data. However, as far as I understand, you need to give the raw data, and not the binned data, as inputs of CHI2TEST2.
Indeed, CHI2TEST2 places the raw data into bins:
bins = unique([x1(:,1); x2(:,1)]); % create a bin for each unique value

类别

在 Help Center 和 File Exchange 中查找有关 Hypothesis Tests 的更多信息

标签

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by