Info

此问题已关闭。 请重新打开它进行编辑或回答。

Problem of integration, the code run but the solution is not satisfying

1 次查看(过去 30 天)
Hi all! I coded the Eq.C.4 to find η(t) and the code works, but, as you can see from the fig. attached, my solution does not match with the one proposed by a scientific paper for the same equation and input data. Any suggestions?
Screenshot (13).png
Roi=916;
Row=1024;
R=Row/Roi;
r=50;
d=50;
%column geometry
H0=50;
l=5;
b=5;
a=(2*l*H0/pi)^0.5;
Area=pi*a^2;
Vol=Area*H0;
%Dinamic of the block
Omega=1;
va=(3*(pi)^(3/2))/(16*sqrt(2))*(Omega*sqrt(l*H0))/(1+pi/4*R*(l/b));
%Surfaceelevation
E=zeros(1,301);
t=0:0.1:30;
for i=1:301
O=@(x,y)(besselj(0,x.*y.*a/d)).*((1-y.^2).^0.5).*y.*besselj(0,x*r/d).*((x.*tanh(x)).^0.5).*sin((((9.81/d*t(i).^2).*x).*tanh(x)).^0.5).*x;
E(i)=integral2(O,0,2000,0,1,'Method','iterated','AbsTol',1e-10,'RelTol',1e-10)
end
E1=-2*(a.^3)/(d^3.5)/(9.81^0.5)*va*d*E;
  6 个评论
Are Mjaavatten
Are Mjaavatten 2019-2-20
I am not able to reproduce the figure from the paper either. Your curve at least resembles the original. Mine is totally different. Here is my attempt:
h = 50;
b = 25.2;
Va = 6.21;
g = 9.81;
r = 50;
a = b/2/h;
int1 = @(x) besselj(0,r/h*x).*(sin(a*x)-a*x.*cos(a*x))/a^3./x.^2;
int2 = @(x,t) sqrt(x.*tanh(x)).*sin(g*t^2/h*x.*tanh(x));
integrand = @(x,t) int1(x).*int2(x,t);
N = 200;
t = linspace(0,5,N);
I = zeros(1,N);
for i = 1:N
fun = @(x) integrand(x,t(i));
I(i) = integral(fun,0,200);
end
eta = -2*a^3*Va/sqrt(g*h)*I;
figure; plot(t,eta)
Increasing the upper integration limit dampens out the wiggles, but the general shape is unchanged. There seems to be two possible explanations:
1) I have made some mistake (misunderstanding or bug).
2) The figure in the original paper is based on different parameters and/or equations.
I leave it to you to try to figure this out.
Tommaso Attili
Tommaso Attili 2019-2-20
Thanks! Yes I plotted your solution. At this point I really don't have idea. Thanks for that.

回答(0 个)

此问题已关闭。

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by