What's the actual difference between versions 'a' and 'b' of MATLAB, other than being 6 months apart?

Question

Alexandre Piccini 2019-4-7

0
链接

此问题的直接链接

https://ww2.mathworks.cn/matlabcentral/answers/454956-what-s-the-actual-difference-between-versions-a-and-b-of-matlab-other-than-being-6-months-apart

评论： Alexandre Piccini 2024-9-11

Hello guys.

I always thought the main difference between versions 'a' and 'b' of MATLAB was 'b' being 6 months "better" than version 'a' and, of course, this means that naturally the version 'b' is going to be a more up-to-date version, with more features as well - being the main intent to have new releases every semester. However, just the other day a friend of mine claimed something I wasn't able to double-check elsewhere:

"Usually the 'a' versions are more stable (...) being 'b' more of a pre-release of version 'a' of the next year [rather than an actual release], having features that have past beta but still can be improved" (and supposedly will be improved and perfected at 'a'). But isn't this the story with just any release? Don't you always implement new things and improve things of the past as necessary?

" 'b' will usually have more features than 'a', however the version 'b' is going to be something around 90% to 100% reliable, while 'a' will always be 100% reliable". Have someone ever come across these reliability concerns once?

(Writings in italic are my comments about the claims, and not part of the claim itself)

Is someone capable of confirming this? I have always seen it as if the real beta release/period takes place just months before the actual release of 'a' and 'b', when Mathworks releases its actual beta version to get feedback. Am I missing something?

2 个评论
显示无隐藏无

Star Strider 2019-4-7

Someone from MathWorks will have to provide the definitive response. In the interim, see if perusing the Release Notes (link) for several releases reveals a pattern.

dpb 2019-4-7

I think your friend is just making up stuff...there's no evidence to that effect at all; and certainly 'a' releases have bugs just as do 'b' releases.

My observation is that TMW releases features into the wild with whichever update is next based on some internal and nondisclosed decision-making process as to whether the particular feature is/is not "ready for prime time".

Some pretty major features have been introduced piecemeal (thinking of datetime as particular example) with it taking several releases for many of the corollary functions to become "datetime aware" and some of the specialty graphs still weren't as of R2018b while the base class came out clear back in R2014b.

That it happend to be a 'b' release is, in my best guess, purely happenstance.

Personally, I'd prefer TMW not worry about the 6-month cycle but release features when they really are "ripe" rather than somewhat piecemeal, but they've got the competitive pressures to deal with.

请先登录，再进行评论。

请先登录，再回答此问题。

Answer 1

Aik-Siong Koh 2021-7-8

4
链接

此回答的直接链接

https://ww2.mathworks.cn/matlabcentral/answers/454956-what-s-the-actual-difference-between-versions-a-and-b-of-matlab-other-than-being-6-months-apart#answer_742888

编辑：dpb 2021-7-8

Twice-Yearly Releases

MathWorks follows a twice-yearly general release schedule, with one release in the March timeframe and a second in the September timeframe. Each general release synchronizes the full MATLAB® and Simulink® product families, delivering new features and bug fixes for existing products and, when available, new products.

More details are at

https://www.mathworks.com/products/new_products/release_model.html

(Converted to active link -- dpb)

2 个评论
显示无隐藏无

dpb 2021-7-8

Adding just a little -- what is acutally different is always just a mix of features and bug fixes (and, occasionally, a new bug :) ); it's like Christmas twice a year; you never know what's going to be under the tree!

Since TMW never talks publicly about features under development nor when such might be released, it's always somewhat of a surprise -- one can go look at prior release notes to get an idea of just how eclectic things can be.

The one downside is that sometimes things get removed (not much that I actively still used, fortunately), but occasionally some of the syntax/behavior changes are problematical in how code functions so if one has production code, one has to be careful.

https://www.mathworks.com/help/matlab/release-notes.html