Replace Discouraged Syntaxes of rand and randn
Description of the Discouraged Syntaxes
In earlier versions of MATLAB®, you controlled the random number generator used by the rand
and randn
functions with the 'seed'
,
'state'
or 'twister'
inputs. For
example:
rand('seed',sd) randn('seed',sd) rand('state',s) randn('state',s) rand('twister',5489)
These syntaxes referred to different types of generators, and they are no longer recommended for the following reasons:
The terms
'seed'
and'state'
are misleading names for the generators.All of the generators except
'twister'
are flawed.They unnecessarily use different generators for
rand
andrandn
.
To assess the impact of replacing discouraged syntaxes in your existing code, execute the following commands at the start of your MATLAB session:
warning('on','MATLAB:RandStream:ActivatingLegacyGenerators') warning('on','MATLAB:RandStream:ReadingInactiveLegacyGeneratorState')
Description of Replacement Syntaxes
Use the rng
function to control the shared generator used by
rand
, randn
,
randi
and all other random number generation functions like
randperm
, sprand
, and so on. To learn
how to use the rng
function when replacing discouraged
syntaxes, take a few moments to understand their function. This should help you to
see which new rng
syntax best suits your needs.
The first input to rand(Generator,s)
or
randn(Generator,s)
specified the type of the generator, as
described here.
|
The v4
and v5
generators are no longer
recommended unless you are trying to exactly reproduce the random numbers generated
in earlier versions of MATLAB. The simplest way to update your code is to use rng
. The rng
function replaces the names for the rand
and
randn
generators as follows.
rand/randn Generator Name | rng Generator Name |
---|---|
'seed' | 'v4' |
'state' |
|
'twister' | 'twister' (recommended) |
Replacement Syntaxes for Initializing the Generator with an Integer Seed
The most common uses of the integer seed sd
in the
rand(Generator,sd)
syntax were to:
Reproduce exactly the same random numbers each time (e.g., by using a seed such as 0, 1, or 3141879)
Try to ensure that MATLAB always gives different random numbers in separate runs (for example, by using a seed such as
sum(100*clock)
)
The following table shows replacements for syntaxes with an integer seed
sd
.
The first column shows the discouraged syntax with
rand
andrandn
.The second column shows how to exactly reproduce the discouraged behavior with the new
rng
function. In most cases, this is done by specifying a legacy generator type such as the v4 or v5 generators, which is no longer recommended.The third column shows the recommended alternative, which does not specify the optional generator type input to
rng
. Therefore, if you always omit theGenerator
input,rand
,randn
, andrandi
just use the default generator type and seed value. The default generator type used at MATLAB startup is the Mersenne Twister generator with seed value of 0. You can change the default algorithm and seed for the random number generator in MATLAB preferences (since R2023b). For more details, seerng
.
Discouraged rand/randn Syntax | Not Recommended: Reproduce Discouraged Behavior Exactly By Specifying Generator Type | Recommended Alternative: Does Not Override Generator Type |
---|---|---|
rand('twister',5489) | rng(5489,'twister') | rng('default') |
rand('seed',sd) | rng(sd,'v4') | rng(sd) |
randn('seed',sd) | ||
rand('state',sd) | rng(sd,'v5uniform') | |
randn('state',sd) | rng(sd,'v5normal') | |
rand('seed',sum(100*clock)) | rng(sum(100*clock),'v4') | rng('shuffle') |
Replacement Syntaxes for Initializing the Generator with a State Vector
The most common use of the state vector (shown here as st
) in
the rand(Generator,st)
syntax was to reproduce exactly the random
numbers generated at a specific point in an algorithm or iteration. For example, you
could use this vector as an aid in debugging.
The rng
function changes the pattern of saving and restoring
the state of the random number generator as shown in the next table. The example in
the left column assumes that you are using the v5
uniform
generator. The example in the right column uses the new syntax, and works for any
generator you use.
Discouraged Syntax Using rand/randn | New Syntax Using rng |
---|---|
% Save v5 generator state. st = rand('state'); % Call rand. x = rand; % Restore v5 generator state. rand('state',st); % Call rand again and hope % for the same results. y = rand |
% Get generator settings. s = rng; % Call rand. x = rand; % Restore previous generator % settings. rng(s); % Call rand again and % get the same results. y = rand |
For a demonstration, see this instructional video.
If You Are Unable to Upgrade from Discouraged Syntax
If there is code that you are not able or not permitted to modify and you know
that it uses the discouraged random number generator control syntaxes, it is
important to remember that when you use that code MATLAB will switch into legacy mode. In legacy mode,
rand
and randn
are controlled by
separate generators, each with their own settings.
Calls to rand
in legacy mode use one of the following:
The
'v4'
generator, controlled byrand('seed', ...)
The
'v5uniform'
generator, controlled byrand('state', ...)
The
'twister'
generator, controlled byrand('twister', ...)
Calls to randn
in legacy mode use one of the
following:
The
'v4'
generator, controlled byrandn('seed', ...)
The
'v5normal'
generator, controlled byrandn('state', ...)
If code that you rely on puts MATLAB into legacy mode, use the following command to escape legacy mode and get back to the default startup generator:
rng('default')
Alternatively, to guard around code that puts MATLAB into legacy mode, use:
s = rng % Save current settings of the generator. ... % Call code using legacy random number generator syntaxes. rng(s) % Restore previous settings of the generator.