setdiff on Simulink VariableUseage

Question

Reuben Symons 2022-2-9

0
链接

此问题的直接链接

https://ww2.mathworks.cn/matlabcentral/answers/1646160-setdiff-on-simulink-variableuseage

回答： Dinesh 2023-12-29

My goal is to identify data dictionary definitions defined in the datadictionary not defined in the model. Using the search function doesn't work as they are referenced data dictionaries.

I have created two variableUseage objects, one from the model and one from the datadictionary I am trying to find unused variables in.

I can see that the two variableUseage objects contain identical entries save for the users paramater which is empty in the one created from the datadictionary. The reference for setdiff states:

setdiff compares the Name, Source, and SourceType properties of the Simulink.VariableUsage objects in VarsIn1 with the same properties of the objects in VarsIn2. If VarsIn1 and VarsIn2 each contain a Simulink.VariableUsage object with the same values for these three properties, the objects describe the same variable, and setdiff does not return an object to describe it.

When I run setdiff I get the entire contents of VarsIn1 back despite manually confirming that most of the variables in varsin1 exist in varsin2 with identical Name, source and SourceType.

function deleteUnusedDD(model)

% model is a string handle for the open model to perform this on.

ddInternal = Simulink.data.dictionary.open(strcat(model, '_internal.sldd'));

iDDVars = getSection(ddInternal,'Design Data');

innerVars = find(iDDVars, '-regexp','DataSource', strcat(model, '_internal.sldd'));

innerUseage = Simulink.VariableUsage({innerVars.Name},strcat(model, '_internal.sldd'));

% %load the model vars

load_system(model);

modelVars = Simulink.findVars(model,'SearchReferencedModels','on','SourceType','data dictionary'); % has 300 vars of which 150 are in innerUseage

toDelete = setdiff(innerUseage,modelVars); % has 154 vars of which 150 are in modelvars

% I expect toDelete to contain 4 vars.

0 个评论
显示 -2更早的评论隐藏 -2更早的评论

请先登录，再进行评论。

请先登录，再回答此问题。

Answer 1

Dinesh 2023-12-29

0
链接

此回答的直接链接

https://ww2.mathworks.cn/matlabcentral/answers/1646160-setdiff-on-simulink-variableuseage#answer_1380166

Hi Reuben,

It seems you're facing an issue with the "setdiff" function when comparing "Simulink.VariableUsage" objects. The function should ideally return variables that are in "VarsIn1" but not in "VarsIn2," based on the "Name," "Source," and "SourceType" properties. If "setdiff" is returning all variables from "VarsIn1," it suggests that it's not finding a match in "VarsIn2" for those variables, even though you have manually confirmed that they should match.

This could be due to several reasons, such as small differences in the properties of the objects that aren't properly visible or an issue with the data type or format of the properties.

To debug this, I believe that you have to manually check and compare the properties of a few "Simulink.VariableUsage" objects from both "VarsIn1" and "VarsIn2" to confirm they are exactly the same.