Inconsistency in fitting function

Question

Sajid Afaque 2023-2-3

0
链接

此问题的直接链接

https://ww2.mathworks.cn/matlabcentral/answers/1905941-inconsistency-in-fitting-function

评论： Sajid Afaque 2023-2-8

在 MATLAB Online 中打开

Hello I am trying to fit a function

I have two similar kind of data, lets name two type of data

a_data
b_data

model is able to fit a_data well each time, but it fails to fit b_data most of the times.

I dont understand why ? The model doesnt throws any error but it results in bad fitting

probably the model is getting struck in bad local minima ,which results in bad fit, but i am not sure of it.

load("b_data.mat")

v = b_data(:,1); %%same in case of b_data

c = b_data(:,2);

function_type=2; %--> a,b,c & d parameter

mcc_best = 0;

figure;

plot(v,c);

hold on;

for i=1:1:200

if function_type == 1

[estimates, model] = fit_C_U_function(v, c);

end

if function_type == 2

[estimates, model] = fit_C_U_function_plus(v, c);

end

[sse, FittedCurve] = model(estimates);

sst = c*transpose(c);

mcc = 1- sse./sst;

if mcc>mcc_best

mcc_best = mcc;

estimates_best = estimates;

FittedCurve_best = FittedCurve;

end

plot(v,FittedCurve_best);

function [estimates, model] = fit_C_U_function_plus(xdata, ydata)

% Call fminsearch with a random starting point.

start_point = rand(1, 4);

model = @expfun;

options = optimset('Display','Off');

estimates = fminsearch(model, start_point,options);

function [sse, FittedCurve] = expfun(params)

a = params(1);

b = params(2);

c = params(3);

d = params(4);

FittedCurve = a + (1-a) .* exp(-b .* (xdata-c).*(xdata-c)) + d.*abs(xdata);

ErrorVector = FittedCurve - ydata;

sse = sum(ErrorVector .^ 2);

end

3 个评论
显示 1更早的评论隐藏 1更早的评论

Torsten 2023-2-3

Taking random initial values for a four-parameter model and hoping for a perfect fit is very optimistic.

Only a few things in this world work automatically - for most of them, one has to invest some time and effort.

Sajid Afaque 2023-2-8

Thanks for the feedback. I have rephrased the questions with snippets. Hopefully now its able to clearly explain

请先登录，再进行评论。

请先登录，再回答此问题。

Answer 1

Askic V 2023-2-3

0
链接

此回答的直接链接

https://ww2.mathworks.cn/matlabcentral/answers/1905941-inconsistency-in-fitting-function#answer_1163166

在 MATLAB Online 中打开

One way to overcome (not 100% guarantee though) this would be the following. If you really have no clue what the coefficient values would be,then you can use random values. In all other function calls inside the loop, you should try to send calculated values as initial values.

So your function

function [estimates, model] = fit_C_U_function_plus(xdata, ydata)

should be

function [estimates, model] = fit_C_U_function_plus(xdata, ydata, initial_val)

I don't see a point why would you use random initialization 200 times, it is much better to use previously calculated values.

1 个评论
显示 -1更早的评论隐藏 -1更早的评论

Sajid Afaque 2023-2-8

在 MATLAB Online 中打开

Thanks for the time. I calculate error after each fit. The idea behind 200 initialisation was to have the best fitting resulting in minimum error out of this 200.

But as you said instead of using random value i will also try to use the calculated value for next trail.

I figured out that the slight change in function definition was helping to get a better fit

FittedCurve = a + (a) .* exp(-b .* (xdata-c).*(xdata-c)) + d.*abs(xdata)
% instead of the earlier one FittedCurve = a + (1-a) .* exp(-b .* (xdata-c).*(xdata-c)) + d.*abs(xdata)

请先登录，再进行评论。