Chain array indexing error to access elements of a function

93 次查看(过去 30 天)
I keep getting an error in trying to access elements of an array that is defined as a function. Consider the foloowing function that demonstrates my issue:
test = @(t) [t, t^2];
which takes in the time parameter, t, and returns a 1x2 array of floats that depend on that value of t. Now, I want to define a function, x = @(t) to be the first element of the 1x2 array returned by test(t).
How can I do this? I have tried the following:
x = @(t) test(t)(1). However, this doesn't work. Specifically, Matlab considers (t)(1) to be a nested index, which is strictly not allowed. The error message returned by Matlab is "Invalid array indexing or function call. Chaining outputs after parenthesis is not supported".
How can I achieve what I described?
Note that test is an example function, my actual function is a little more involved.
EDIT (Additional info based on answers)
Based on answer I received, it is worth clarifying that I do not have access to the function x(t). I.e. I am working with vectors that define the solution, which in our above example would read
test = @(t) [ x(t), y(t), z(t) ] % This step is yielding after some pre-calculation that bears no signifcance to the question
The rest of the calculation requires knowledge of just x(t) and z(t), so I would like to define these functions by accessing elements of test.
  1 个评论
Steven Lord
Steven Lord 2023-4-26
which takes in the time parameter, t, and returns a 1x2 array of floats that depend on that value of t.
It does that under certain circumstances. In general it returns an array with the same size as t except in dimension 2, where the size is twice as large as t's size in dimension 2.
test = @(t) [t, t^2];
t = magic(4)
t = 4×4
16 2 3 13 5 11 10 8 9 7 6 12 4 14 15 1
result = test(t)
result = 4×8
16 2 3 13 345 257 281 273 5 11 10 8 257 313 305 281 9 7 6 12 281 305 313 257 4 14 15 1 273 281 257 345
[size(t); size(result)]
ans = 2×2
4 4 4 8
So would you really want the second element of the output or the second half of the output?

请先登录,再进行评论。

回答(2 个)

VBBV
VBBV 2023-4-26
编辑:VBBV 2023-4-26
test = @(t) [t, t^2]
test = function_handle with value:
@(t)[t,t^2]
% test using t = 10
y = test(10);
% define e.g function
x = @(t) t.^2+2*t
x = function_handle with value:
@(t)t.^2+2*t
% get the value of function using first value returned by test
x(y(1))
ans = 120
  2 个评论
Jasminder
Jasminder 2023-4-26
Hi VBBV, I think there is a misunderstanding on what I asked. I want x(t) to be defined as the first element of test. In Mathematica notation, this could be:
x = @(t) test(t)(1)
In this simple example, of course, this should give
x=@(t) t,
but the syntax test(t)(1) in invalid. How to get around this?
VBBV
VBBV 2023-4-26
编辑:VBBV 2023-4-26
ok, i guess you need a cell array to build function as follows
x = @(t) t;
y = @(t) t^2;
% e.g function
test = {x , y}
test = 1×2 cell array
{@(t)t} {@(t)t^2}
% call or access the first element of e.g function
x = test(1)
x = 1×1 cell array
{@(t)t}
% do something next
you can also extend test function at your will

请先登录,再进行评论。


chicken vector
chicken vector 2023-4-26
The fact that you can't concatenate indexing is a well-known Matlab limitation whose implementation has already been suggested on the forum.
The best option that you have is to use:
x = @(t) t
By doing so you are also saving computational time because you want to compute test to only access the first element is a waste of resources.
  2 个评论
Jasminder
Jasminder 2023-4-26
As the note in the OP suggests, I do not in fact know what the function x is. I am working with vectors and so I can determine (after some calculation) the array [x(t), y(t), z(t)]. The rest of the calculation then requires just x(t) and z(t). Therefore, this suggestion does not work. Do you know of an alternative approach?
chicken vector
chicken vector 2023-4-26
This might be too intricate for your needs but it works:
test = @(t) [t,t^2];
x = @(t) extractFirstTestValue(test,t);
function firstValue = extractFirstTestValue(test,t)
testValue = test(t);
firstValue = testValue(1);
end

请先登录,再进行评论。

类别

Help CenterFile Exchange 中查找有关 Data Type Identification 的更多信息

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by