evalfr for discrete systems gives strange results

17 次查看(过去 30 天)
Hi! I've got some strange behaviour from the function evalfr. Basically I use evalfr to extract the frequency response of a system in the form of a complex number (which has a magnitude and phase).
When I do this for a continuous system everything works fine. If I then discretize the system I get results I cannot explain. The obtained response for the discrete system appears to vary with the sampling time. (I check/compare the results to the bode function). Can someone take a look/explain?
%%continuous system (works as expected)
clear
close all
sys2 = tf([4700 4393 3.245e08],[1 7.574 1.202e5 0 0]);
bode(sys2), grid on
feval = 50 %evaluation point in Hz
res2 = evalfr(sys2,feval*2*pi*i); %extract frequency response as a complex number
mag2 = mag2db(abs(res2)) %convert magnitude to db
pha2 = angle(res2)*180/pi %obtain angle and convert to degrees
[mag2c,pha2c] = bode(sys2,feval*2*pi); %use the bode command to check
mag2c = mag2db(mag2c)
pha2c
%MAG2 AND MAG2C SHOULD MATCH (same for phase)
%%Discretized system (doesnt work as expected)
close all
T = 1/1000; %sample time
sys3 = c2d(sys2,T); %discretize
bode(sys3), grid on
res3 = evalfr(sys3,feval*2*pi*i);
mag3 = mag2db(abs(res3))
pha3 = angle(res3)*180/pi
[mag3c,pha3c] = bode(sys3,feval*2*pi);
mag3c = mag2db(mag3c)
pha3c
%MAG3 AND MAG3C SHOULD MATCH (same for phase)

采纳的回答

Chad MacDonald
Chad MacDonald 2017-5-15
The evalfr command allows you to evaluate the frequency response of a system at any point in the complex plane. However, bode evaluates points only on the:
  • Imaginary axis (s = jw) for continuous-time systems.
  • Unit circle (z = e^jwT) for discrete-time systems.
Therefore, the reason you are getting inconsistent results between bode and evalfr is that you are using the s-domain complex variable with your discrete-time system rather than the z-domain variable.
The following code shows how to get the same response at a given frequency using bode and evalfr:
%%Create discrete-time system.
T = 1/1000;
sys = tf([4700 4393 3.245e08],[1 7.574 1.202e5 0 0],T);
%%Frequency = 50 Hz
w = 50*2*pi;
%%bode result
[magB,phaseB] = bode(sys,w)
%%evalfr result for z = e^jwT
resultE = evalfr(sys,exp(j*w*T));
magE = abs(resultE)
phaseE = angle(resultE)*180/pi
This information is not clearly conveyed in the documentation. I've updated the enhancement request in our tracking system, and we will update the documentation in a future release.

更多回答(0 个)

类别

Help CenterFile Exchange 中查找有关 Get Started with Control System Toolbox 的更多信息

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by