Bug in Persistent variables? Simulink M-function

2018 1 30
1 个回答
更新时间：2022 9 8
5 次查看（30 天）

1 个投票

I am unable to initialize a Persistent variable. Here's a snippet of code in a Simulink M-function which does not actually set 'a' no matter what I do:
persistent a
if isempty(a)
a = 1;
end
Either printing out 'a' or evaluating 'a' gives
a=[]
...NOT a=1 as it should.
It doesn't matter what the variable name is, or what I try to set it to, or how many variables there are. This bug happens with two different sets of Persistent Variables.
However, oddly, later on in the SAME M-function, I do another persistent declaration using the exact same method and there initialization DOES work.
I tried this in both R2016a and 2017b
What is going on?

4 个评论
显示 2更早的评论 隐藏 2更早的评论

John Pryce
John Pryce 2019-5-25
编辑：John Pryce 2019-5-25
This bug exists. My "main program" is a function with input arguments and the crash occurs some levels down inside an a function that is called by fzero(), so isolating the error was tricky.
I confirm what John says "It doesn't matter what the variable name is, or what I try to set it to". Further:
  • If it crashes and I immediately re-run with the same inputs it always goes on crashing.
  • If I then run with different inputs it may work correctly.
  • If after doing something else I re-run with the original inputs that caused the crash it may work correctly.
  • Changing the layout of code, or changing nearby code, may change it between working and crashing. E.g. I originally had if nargin>4, it = it0; end below, and changing it to what's written cured the problem – so I thought! But it reappeared with other inputs.
  • Stepping through in the debugger, with argument it0 absent so nargin>4 is false, I found that though it skipped the it = it0; statement, it nonetheless changed the value of it to an unpredictable value (e.g. 165) while going from if to end.
  • Once past this perilous initialisation, it seems it behaves as it should do.
The piece of code in question is
function [x,xp,it1] = searchAndInterp(tt,xx,xxp,t,it0)
% some comments
persistent it %Seems most economical way to implement this
itbefore=it %!!!DEBUGGING
if nargin>4
it = it0;
end
if isempty(it), it=1; end
itafter=it %!!!DEBUGGING
%...
That evidence should help locate where in the compiler the error is located. I have a file of relevant command window output but can't see how to attach it.
I'm using
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MATLAB Version: 9.5.0.944444 (R2018b)
Operating System: Mac OS X Version: 10.14.4 Build: 18E226
Java Version: Java 1.8.0_152-b16 with Oracle Corporation Java HotSpot(TM) 64-Bit Server VM mixed mode
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
John
John 2019-5-25
Mathworks, any comment?
Odd indeed that it's still not fixed.
They never responded to the original bug either.
amin ya
amin ya 2020-1-29
I can confirm that this is a bug. I am on Matlab 2019b Update 3
John
John 2020-1-29
Amin, it's sad to see this major bug still exists after 2 years.
There has been no reply from Mathworks -- Mathworks, are there any plans to resolve this bug?

请先登录，再进行评论。

请先登录，再回答此问题。

回答（1 个）

John
John 2018-1-31

0 个投票

Okay, now I'm certain it's a BUG. The code WILL -- or will NOT -- properly initialize a variable depending on where it is located in the function, and what is around it. Even if the init is unrelated to the surrounding code.
Eg
<code 1>
persistent a
if isempty(a)
a = 1;
end
<code 2>
<code 3>
might NOT work, but
<code 1>
<code 2>
persistent a
if isempty(a)
a = 1;
end
<code 3>
WILL work.
The surrounding Code 1, 2, 3 are completely unrelated to the variable 'a'. Likewise, an init that DID work at a certain section will no longer work if it is moved.
Unfortunately, I cannot make the code work in places that I need it to, as it seems to be random why it works or is buggy.
Mathworks -- any response?

2 个评论
显示 无 隐藏 无

Youssef Ismail
Youssef Ismail 2022-9-8
I also have the same problem has it been solved?
John
John 2022-9-8
编辑：John 2022-9-8
Not resolved to my knowledge, unfortunately. You could try my workaround of finding a code order that may work for your code.

请先登录，再进行评论。

类别

在 帮助中心 和 File Exchange 中查找有关 Startup and Shutdown 的更多信息

标签

提问:

John
John
2018-1-30

编辑：

John
John
2022-9-8

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by