Can I recover only the diagonal elements of A' * B with SVD vectors of A and B?

Question

Xiaohan Du 2018-6-28

0
链接

此问题的直接链接

https://ww2.mathworks.cn/matlabcentral/answers/407984-can-i-recover-only-the-diagonal-elements-of-a-b-with-svd-vectors-of-a-and-b

回答： Anton Semechko 2018-6-28

Hi all,

Imagine I have 2 matrices A and B and I need the diagonal elements of (A' * B). If say A and B are both m*n matrices which contains column vectors as follows:

A = [a1, ..., an];
B = [b1, ..., bn];

Then the diagonal elements of (A' * B) can be calculated by the vector products of the paired vectors a1'*b1, a2'*b2, ..., an' * bn.

Now if I perform economy size SVD to A and B:

[ua, sa, va] = svd(A, 'econ');
[ub, sb, vb] = svd(B, 'econ');

Then my question is: can I calculate only the diagonal elements of (A' * B) with SVD components [ua, sa, va] and [ub, sb, vb]? Notice only the diagonal elements, none of the other elements can be computed.

My understanding is no, I can't. Because if recovering (A' * B) by the SVD components, say

A' * B = (ua1 * sa1 * va1')' * (ub1 * sb1 * vb1') + ... + (uan * san * van')' * (ubn * sbn * vbn')

then each component product

(uan * san * van')' * (ubn * sbn * vbn')

is a full m*n matrix, which only recovers part of the whole diagonal line. Summing all n full m*n matrices will recover the matrix (A' * B), but this is not cheaper than computing (A' * B), because it involves computation of all elements of (A' * B). So if SVD is involved, there is no efficient way of getting diagonal elements of (A' * B) by only computing the diagonal elements.

I don't know if I'm right, and please excuse me if it's not so clear.

Many thanks!

0 个评论
显示 -2更早的评论隐藏 -2更早的评论

请先登录，再进行评论。

请先登录，再回答此问题。

Answer 1

Anton Semechko 2018-6-28

0
链接

此回答的直接链接

https://ww2.mathworks.cn/matlabcentral/answers/407984-can-i-recover-only-the-diagonal-elements-of-a-b-with-svd-vectors-of-a-and-b#answer_326770

在 MATLAB Online 中打开

i-th diagonal of A'*B equals dot product of the i-th columns of A and B. Here is a demo showing how to recover only the diagonals of A'*B using SVDs of A and B:

% Generate two M-by-N matrices 
M=100;
N=100;
A=randn(M,N);
B=randn(M,N);
% Get SVDs
[Ua,Da,Va]=svd(A,0);
[Ub,Db,Vb]=svd(B,0);
% Pre-multiply D and V'
Va=Da*Va';
Vb=Db*Vb';
% Get diagonal entries of C=A'*B; i-th diagonal element = dot product between i-th columns of A and B
C_diag=zeros(N,1);
for n=1:N    
    A_n=Ua*Va(:,n); % n-th column of A <--> n-th row of transpose(A)
    B_n=Ub*Vb(:,n); % n-th column of B
    C_diag(n)=A_n'*B_n;    
end
% Verify computed solution 
C_diag_ref=diag(A'*B);
E_max=max(abs(C_diag-C_diag_ref));
fprintf('Maximum absolute error: %.10E\n',E_max)