Center of mass problem

Question

Hugo Matias 2018-11-28

0
链接

此问题的直接链接

https://ww2.mathworks.cn/matlabcentral/answers/432650-center-of-mass-problem

评论： Hugo Matias 2018-11-30

Imagine a matrix as if you're looking at a ship from above.

I have a ship and I want to store 21 containers on it, as close as possible to its center of mass.

The center of mass of the ship is (2,3) (line 2 and column 3)

The 21 containers and respective Kg's are:

containers=[100,70,30,70,10,10,100,30,70,100,10,30,30,70,100,10,70,30,70,10,10]

What code do I use in order to generate a matrix (3x7) where the cointainers are distributed in a way that the center of mass remains as close as possible to the original one (2,3).

Thanks

10 个评论
显示 8更早的评论隐藏 8更早的评论

Bob Thompson 2018-11-29

If you calculate the center of gravity between two equal mass objects then the CG will be halfway between them. Using this idea, if you want to have a CG in a specific location, and you have two equal size objects, you know that you need to place them in a line, each with equal distance to the CM.

Since you have a specific location you're trying to place the CG you can begin relatively similarly. Sum up all of your mass, 1030, and then divide it by two, 515, then you know that you want to get as close as you can to having 515 in front of the CG, and half in back. The real problem is more complicated than that because you have differing distances and placement that is directly in line with the ideal CG, but it's a place to start.

Similarly, for the side to side CG, you have three rows. so divide the total by three, ~343, and lay out the containers so that each row has approximately that much weight. If one of the rows has more, it could be best if it is the center one, because that one is in line with the ideal CG, and will not throw your CG off laterally.

Please, keep in mind that this is very much an engineering method of thinking, and will not truly consider ALL possible options, just allow you to think logically about how to place the containers in a reasonably efficient way.

Hugo Matias 2018-11-30

Thank you very much Bob

Image Analyst 2018-11-30

编辑：Image Analyst 2018-11-30

What is the size and shape of the objects? Obviously if they're dense circular lead rods then they can be packed closer to the center than if they were rectangular mattresses of the same weight.

请先登录，再进行评论。

请先登录，再回答此问题。

Answer 1

Jim Riggs 2018-11-29

0
链接

此回答的直接链接

https://ww2.mathworks.cn/matlabcentral/answers/432650-center-of-mass-problem#answer_349663

编辑：Jim Riggs 2018-11-30

I wrote a function to compute the CG in X and Y. Then I used this function to find a solution by inspection (i.e. I manualy adjusted the positions until I found an answer )

function [Xcg, Ycg] = moment(D);
[row,col]=size(D);
Wtot = sum(sum(D));  % total weight of all containers
Xsum=0;
Ysum=0;
for i=1:row
    for j=1:col
        Xmom = D(i,j)*j;  % X moment of container i,j
        Ymom = D(i,j)*i;  % Y moment of container i,j
        Xsum = Xsum + Xmom;  % total X moment
        Ysum = Ysum + Ymom;  % total Y moment
    end
end
Xcg = Xmom/Wtot;
Ycg = Ysum/Wtot;
end

I use this function to verify that the following matrix has a CG at 3,2: (column 3, row 2):

D = [100,  70,  70,  10,  30,  10,  30;...
     100, 100,  30,  70,  10,  10,  70;...
     100,  70,  70,  10,  30,  10,  30]
 

6 个评论
显示 4更早的评论隐藏 4更早的评论

Jim Riggs 2018-11-30

编辑：Jim Riggs 2018-11-30

I will explain how I aproach the problem. The sample data that you gave is pretty easy to work with, since there are only 4 different container weights. Writing an algorithm to do this might be tricky.

First, recignize that to obtain a CG in column 3 (where there are 7 colmns) will require significantly "front-loading" the system. I.e. you need the heavy ones in the first two columns in order to ballance the rest which will have a much longer moment arm.

Second, wherever there is an odd number of containers with the same weight, you know that one of these has to go in row #2 in order to maintain top-to-bottom symmetry.

So I started by counting the number of weight bins:

Only the 30# bin is odd, so one of the 30's has to go in row 2.

I put three of the 100's in column 1 for maximum forward leverage, and the remaining 100 must now go in row 2, so this gives an initial layout of:

 ..   ..   ..   ..   ..   ..   ..
 100  ..   ..   30   ..   ..   ..
 ..   ..   ..   ..   ..   ..   ..

The rest are allocated in pairs, maintainin symmetry in row 1 and row 3.

Again, I put the heaviest ones up front, and the lighter ones in the back. e.g.

 70  70   30  30  10  10
100  70   70  30  10  10
 70  70   30  30  10  10

After I had an initial allocation of all 21, I calculate the X,Y CG position and find that it is too far forward. (X = 2.6893) We need to move this back to X=3, so now I simply start trading lighter ones that are aft with heavier ones that are forward until I end up with X CG at X=3. As long as I keep row 1 and row 3 the same, the Y cg will always stay right at row 2.

First, I trade the70 and the 10 in the middle row:

 70  70  30  30  10  10
100  10  70  30  10  70
 70  70  30  30  10  10 

This results in an X cg at 2.9223, so now we are very close.

Next, trade the other 70 and 10 in the midle row:

 70  70  30  30  10  10
100  10  10  30  70  70
 70  70  30  30  10  10

This results in Xcg = 3.0388. This was a bit too much. So now trade the 70 and 30 in the middle row:

 70  70  30  30  10  10
100  10  10  70  30  70
 70  70  30  30  10  10

This results in Xcg = 3, which is just what we want.

Jim Riggs 2018-11-30

For complex problems like this, you need to do a lot of planning. Start with a flow chart and write in words (like I have done, above) the steos that you want to do. Then translate each step into code, breaking it down into more detail as you go.

So, it might go something like:

Step 1 make an initial allocation of the 21 containers.

Step 2 evaluate CG

Step 3 Adjust CG

Itterate step 2 and 3 until done.

Break down step 1 into sub-steps:

Make an initial alloocation:

- Sort containers into bins

- Identify bins with odd numbers

- Place odd container numbers in row 2

- Allocate remaining container pairs:

* Sort from heaviest to lighest

* Place pairs in rows 1 & 3, from heavy to light.

* Place remainder in row 2

etc..

As you go, you will identify additional functions that need to be performed, such as

- keep track of allocated/non-allocated containers

- keep track of used/available positions in the container array

Now translate each step into code and you are on your way. Obviously, this will be a whole lot of work.

Hugo Matias 2018-11-30

The problem is I don't know how to place them! That's what i'm not understanding how I do it!

请先登录，再进行评论。

Center of mass problem

10 个评论
显示 8更早的评论隐藏 8更早的评论

回答（1 个）

6 个评论
显示 4更早的评论隐藏 4更早的评论

另请参阅

类别

标签

Community Treasure Hunt

Center of mass problem

10 个评论 显示 8更早的评论隐藏 8更早的评论

回答（1 个）

6 个评论 显示 4更早的评论隐藏 4更早的评论

另请参阅

类别

标签

Community Treasure Hunt

WeChat

10 个评论
显示 8更早的评论隐藏 8更早的评论

6 个评论
显示 4更早的评论隐藏 4更早的评论