Impossible Ax=b is solved by linesolve(A,b) and mldivide(A,B)

2 次查看(过去 30 天)
A=[-1 2 3;0 1 -1;2 0 5;1 3 2]
B=[1 1 1 1]'
x=linsolve(A,B)
x =
0.1111
0.3333
0.1111
x=mldivide(A,B)
x =
0.1111
0.3333
0.1111
HOwever A*x
ans =
0.8889
0.2222
0.7778
1.3333
and b= [1 1 1 1]'
If I solve the system in paper, the system is impossible but matlab says it´s possible. When I test matlab answer, it is wrong. If I do A=sym([-1 2 3;0 1 -1;2 0 5;1 3 2])
colspace(A) A =
[ -1, 2, 3] [ 0, 1, -1] [ 2, 0, 5] [ 1, 3, 2]
ans =
[ 1, 0, 0] [ 0, 1, 0] [ 0, 0, 1] [ 1/3, 7/3, 2/3]
The system seems possible but I think it isn't. Can someone tell me what's going on? How do I know if the system is possible?

采纳的回答

Matt Fig
Matt Fig 2012-8-14
编辑:Matt Fig 2012-8-14
From the documentation:
" If A is an m-by-n matrix with m ~= n and B is a column vector with m components, or a matrix with several such columns, then X = A\B is the solution in the least squares sense to the under- or overdetermined system of equations AX = B. In other words, X minimizes norm(A*X - B), the length of the vector AX - B. The rank k of A is determined from the QR decomposition with column pivoting. The computed solution X has at most k nonzero elements per column. If k < n, this is usually not the same solution as x = pinv(A)*B, which returns a least squares solution. "
You have 4 equations and 3 unknowns. This is an overdetermined system, so MATLAB is following the documentation.
  5 个评论
Matt Fig
Matt Fig 2012-8-14
Sure, just make a little function.
isexact = @(A,x,B) max((A*x-B))<1e-13; % Choose your tol.
Now,
A=[-1 2 3;0 1 -1;2 0 5;1 3 2];
B=[1 1 1 1]';
x = A\B;
isexact(A,x,B) % Returns 0 == not exact.
But, let's try with:
A=[-1 2 3;0 1 -1;2 0 5];
B=[2 3 4]';
x = A\B;
isexact(A,x,B) % Returns 1 == yes exact

请先登录,再进行评论。

更多回答(0 个)

类别

Help CenterFile Exchange 中查找有关 Linear Algebra 的更多信息

标签

尚未输入任何标签。

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by