Why does function become slower when placed in spmd block?

Question

Wenjun Zhang 2019-12-5

0
链接

此问题的直接链接

https://ww2.mathworks.cn/matlabcentral/answers/494922-why-does-function-become-slower-when-placed-in-spmd-block

评论： Wenjun Zhang 2019-12-5

Hi all,

I am using spmd to evaluate a function. However, I find that when I put the function into a spmd block, it becomes slower. I use the code below to test this

nlab = 4;  % number of cores in use
nrep = 1e4; % repeatition time
%% configure parallel pool
obj = gcp('nocreate');
if isempty(obj)
    parpool('local', nlab);
elseif obj.NumWorkers ~= nlab
    delete(obj);
    parpool('local', nlab);
end
%% normal
a = rand(1e5, 1); % random data
t = 0;
for lab = 1:nlab
    % this is to simulate spmd in a non-parallel manner
    for repeat = 1:nrep
        tic;
        fun(a,lab);
        t1=toc;
        t = t + t1; % record time and sum
    end
end
fprintf('normal time %.3f\n', t);
%% spmd
t = 0;
spmd
    b = sum(a);
    for repeat = 1:nrep
        tic;
        fun(a,labindex);
        t1=toc;
        t = t + t1;
    end
end
ttot = 0;
for ii = 1:nlab
    ttot = ttot + t{ii};
end
fprintf('spmd time %.3f\n', ttot);
% below is a time-consuming test function
function y = fun(a, k)
y=0;
    for l = 1:length(a)
        y = y + k*a(l);
    end
end

The result shows that, for nlab = 8 (my computer has 8 cores), normal time is 8.9 seconds while spmd time is 24.4 seconds; for nlab = 4, normal time is 4.4 seconds while spmd time is 6.3 seconds; and for nlab = 1, both of them are 1.1 seconds.

It turns out that the more cores I use, the slower the function is. My guess is that when evaluating a function, MATLAB itself is actually using multiple cores evenif not in parallel mode. When I occupy all cores by using spmd, the MATLAB has only one core to use when evaluating a function so that it becomes slow.

Does anyone know the reason and possible solutions?

I was hoping to increase my program by nearly nlab times, however now it can only speed up for approximately twice. I would appreciate any ideas.

0 个评论
显示 -2更早的评论隐藏 -2更早的评论

请先登录，再进行评论。

请先登录，再回答此问题。

Answer 1

Edric Ellis 2019-12-5

0
链接

此回答的直接链接

https://ww2.mathworks.cn/matlabcentral/answers/494922-why-does-function-become-slower-when-placed-in-spmd-block#answer_404888

Your desktop MATLAB client can use "built-in multithreading" for certain operations. By default, workers in a parallel pool use a single computational thread - because the expectation is that you'll run as many workers as you have physical cores in your system.

Therefore, if your program is able to take advantage of MATLAB's built-in multithreading already, then there is no possible benefit to using local workers - you're already at the limits of what your hardware can achieve. To get even better performance, you need additional resources, perhaps in the form of a MATLAB Parallel Server installation.