Not sure what happened. But it works for both auto and manual tuning.
% Plant
Gp = tf(1, [1 10 20])
% PID (Auto)
Gc1 = pidtune(Gp, 'PID')
Gcl1 = feedback(Gc1*Gp, 1);
% PIDF (Manual)
kp = 32.94;
ki = 86.88;
kd = 0.3632;
Tf = 0.1208;
Gc = pid(kp, ki, kd, Tf)
Gcl2= feedback(Gc*Gp, 1);
% Step responses
step(Gcl1, 2), hold on
step(Gcl2, 2), grid on
legend('PID', 'PIDF')


