Multi-target tracking "assignDet​ectionsToT​racks" function has unexpected results?

2020 7 2
1 个回答
回答已采纳
更新时间：2020 9 12
21 次查看（30 天）

0 个投票

When I use the "assignDetectionsToTracks" function, the 5th (row) tracking is associated with the (1)th col detection, and the threshold(costOfNonAssignment=1) I set is 1, and there should be no correlation. Why?
cost = [2.62407,1.93346,4.28524,0.0126375;
1.34658,3.33612,0.769382,3.78107;
2.04141,0.012594,3.98619,1.92012;
3.35982,2.04044,5.14111,1.01901;
1.59666,3.05409,2.13898,2.69844;
4.54989,6.35886,3.17712,6.65899];
costOfNonAssignment = 1;
[assignment,unassignedTracks,unassignedDetections] = ...
assignDetectionsToTracks(cost,costOfNonAssignment)
assignment =
4×2 uint32 matrix
5 1
3 2
2 3
1 4
unassignedTracks =
2×1 uint32 column vector
4
6
unassignedDetections =
0×1 empty uint32 column vector
As can be seen from the result assignment, the fifth track is associated with the first detection data, and the cost between them is 1.59666, and the threshold I set is 1, the cost is greater than the threshold, why the fifth track Related to the first test? Shouldn’t it belong to unassignedTracks?

请先登录，再回答此问题。

 采纳的回答

Elad Kivelevitch
Elad Kivelevitch 2020-9-8

0 个投票

The fifth row / first column is associated because if these were not associated you would incure a cost of unassignment for both row and column, meaning 1+1 = 2. 2 is greater than 1.59666 so the assignment is favored instead of unasignment.

3 个评论
显示 1更早的评论 隐藏 1更早的评论

xingxingcui
xingxingcui 2020-9-11
（chinese）你说的“1”意思是指未分配的行和列的个数吗？我的理解应该是跟踪和检测之间的距离阈值；试想下，把第5行第一列的值由1.5966改为2.5966，这样结果是我预期的样子，第一个检测值将会是未分配的检测（新检测值），而按照你的意思“meaning 1+1 = 2. 2 is greater than 1.59666 so the assignment is favored instead of unasignment.”，请问该如何理解这句话呢？
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(english) Do you mean the number of unallocated rows and columns by "1"? My understanding should be the distance threshold between tracking and detection; imagine changing the value in the first column of row 5 from 1.5966 to 2.5966, so the result is what I expected, the first detection value will be unassigned According to your meaning, "meaning 1+1 = 2. 2 is greater than 1.59666 so the assignment is favored instead of unasignment." How do you understand this sentence? Seems to be unexplainable in the new situation?
cost = [2.62407,1.93346,4.28524,0.0126375;
1.34658,3.33612,0.769382,3.78107;
2.04141,0.012594,3.98619,1.92012;
3.35982,2.04044,5.14111,1.01901;
2.59666,3.05409,2.13898,2.69844;
4.54989,6.35886,3.17712,6.65899];
costOfNonAssignment = 1;
[assignment,unassignedTracks,unassignedDetections] = ...
assignDetectionsToTracks(cost,costOfNonAssignment)
assignment =
3×2 uint32 matrix
3 2
2 3
1 4
unassignedTracks =
3×1 uint32 column vector
4
5
6
unassignedDetections =
uint32
1
Elad Kivelevitch
Elad Kivelevitch 2020-9-11
Yes, exactly.
Ignoring all the other assignments made for this assignment, there are two options to assign row 5 to column 1 or not to assign row 5 to column 1.
If you assign row 5 to column 1, you have a cost of 1.59666.
If you don't assign them, row 5 is unassigned and column 1 is unassigned. This unassignment has a cost of:
  • Not assigning row 5: cost = 1
  • Not assigning column 1: cost = 1
  • Total cost of not assigning row 5 and column 1 = 2
Since the cost of assignment is 1.59666 and the cost of not assiging is 2, the algorithm correctly chooses to assign.
If you want to change that, you can reduce the cost of unassignment to 0.5, which is the equivalent of what you're looking for.
xingxingcui
xingxingcui 2020-9-12
Thank you for your detailed explanation, 1+1=2, and the two 1s represent "unassignedTrackCost" and "unassignedDetectionCost" respectively. I can explain it by specifying the two costs in detail in the following way.
unassignedTrackCost = 0.5;
unassignedDetectionCost = 1;
[assignment,unassignedTracks,unassignedDetections] = ...
assignDetectionsToTracks(cost,unassignedTrackCost,unassignedDetectionCost)

请先登录，再进行评论。

更多回答（0 个）

类别

在 帮助中心 和 File Exchange 中查找有关 Track Objects and Estimate Motion 的更多信息

产品

版本

R2020a

标签

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by