# problem with ginput when having 2 axes in the same figure

12 views (last 30 days)
Alexander on 9 Jan 2013
I have a figure containing 2 axes, the first axes ax(1) contains a line object, it is a spectrum y = y(k). The x-axis here is inverse. The second axes ax(2) ('color','none') is just overlaid and does not contain any graphic object. It's x-axis on top is the (not reversed) wavelength.(The x-limits of the second are adjusted, so that both x-axis have the appropriate positions, e.g. k=0.1 --> x=10 stacked) However, this is to my knowledge the only way in MATLAB to achieve a second reverse x-axis for the same curve in a loglog diagram.
My problem: I want to get two x-coordinates in ax(1) by [x,~]=ginput(2); To be sure it is the right axes I use set(gcf,'CurrentAxes',ax(1))
Now, when I look at the resulting x values, they do come from ax(2), not from ax(1). I haven't any clue why this doesn't work.
Any help is much appreciated.

Alexander on 9 Jan 2013
a code snippet, how the plot is produced
figure
ax(1)=axes;
line(k,y)
set(gca,'xscale','log','yscale','log')
xlim1=get(gca,'xlim');
xlim2=1./fliplr(xlim1);
ax(2) = axes('Position',get(ax(1),'Position'),'XAxisLocation','Top', ...
'Color','none','XDir','reverse', ...
'xscale','log','yscale','log','xlim',xlim2);
Walter Roberson on 9 Jan 2013
Try setting HitTest off for the second axis.
Alexander on 10 Jan 2013
Thanks Walter. With
set(ax(2),'HitTest','off')
it works. But why this behaviour?
In the help page for "ginput" is stated that "ginput raises crosshairs in the current axes". Has this to do with the stack of the two axes?
Thanks.

Wendy Fullam on 11 Jan 2013
"Try setting HitTest off for the second axis."
set(ax(2),'HitTest','off')