Issue with calling variables through multiple functions, not enough input arguments

Question

James Kennedy 2021-1-29

0
链接

此问题的直接链接

https://ww2.mathworks.cn/matlabcentral/answers/730033-issue-with-calling-variables-through-multiple-functions-not-enough-input-arguments

评论： Walter Roberson 2021-1-29

Hi all, I'm still farily inexperienced with matlab. I am trying to break up an equation into smaller parts (the 4 functions) to make it easier to check/modify when I integrate the Gammasigma function but I keep getting 'not enough input arguments,' and the error lists every function as part of the error. I know that I am doing something wrong with the variable calls but I am not sure what specifically my issue is or how to fix it.

syms Egam
ECrit = 5;sigmaT = 1; me = 510;
compton1 = vpaintegral(Gammasigma,Egam,15,30);
compton2 = vpaintegral(Gammasigma,Egam,11,30);
compton = compton1/compton2;
function Gs = Gammasigma(Egam,ECrit,sigmaT,me)
Gs = (exp(-exp(-((log(Egam)+1.2)./(.8)))-((log(Egam)+1.2)./(.8))+1)).*s3;
end
function sigma3 = s3(Egam,ECrit,sigmaT,me)
sigma3 = s2+(3.*sigmaT)./(8).*(1)./(((Egam)./(me)).^3).*(1-((Egam)./(me))-(1+2.*((Egam)./(me)))./(1+((Egam)./(me)) ...
    .*(1-(1-(me)./(Egam).*((ECrit)./(Egam))./(1-(ECrit)./(Egam)))))-((Egam)./(me)).*(1-(me)./(Egam).*((ECrit)./(Egam))./(1-(ECrit)./(Egam))));
end
function sigma2 = s2(Egam,ECrit,sigmaT,me)
sigma2 = s1+(3.*sigmaT)./(8).*(1)./(2.*((Egam)./(me))).*((1)./(1+((Egam)./(me)).*(1-(1-(me)./(Egam).*((ECrit)./(Egam)) ...
    ./(1-(ECrit)./(Egam))))).^2-(1)./(1+2.*((Egam)./(me))).^2);
end
function sigma1 = s1(Egam,ECrit,sigmaT,me)
sigma1 = (3.*sigmaT)./(8).*((((Egam)./(me)).^2-2.*((Egam)./(me))-2)./(((Egam)./(me)).^3).*log((1+2.*((Egam)./(me))) ...
    ./(1+((Egam)./(me)).*(1-(1-(me)./(Egam).*((ECrit)./(Egam))./(1-(ECrit)./(Egam)))))));
end

Any help would be greatly appreciated!

0 个评论
显示 -2更早的评论隐藏 -2更早的评论

请先登录，再进行评论。

请先登录，再回答此问题。

Answer 1

Walter Roberson 2021-1-29

0
链接

此回答的直接链接

https://ww2.mathworks.cn/matlabcentral/answers/730033-issue-with-calling-variables-through-multiple-functions-not-enough-input-arguments#answer_609033

在 MATLAB Online 中打开

function Gs = Gammasigma(Egam,ECrit,sigmaT,me)
Gs = (exp(-exp(-((log(Egam)+1.2)./(.8)))-((log(Egam)+1.2)./(.8))+1)).*s3;

That invokes the function s3 without passing any input arguments.

Remember that s3 might have been written

function sigma3 = s3(me_,sigmaT_,Egam_,ECrit_)
sigma3 = s2+(3.*sigmaT_)./(8).*(1)./(((Egam_)./(me_)).^3).*(1-((Egam_)./(me_))-(1+2.*((Egam_)./(me_)))./(1+((Egam_)./(me_)) ...
    .*(1-(1-(me_)./(Egam_).*((ECrit_)./(Egam_))./(1-(ECrit_)./(Egam_)))))-((Egam_)./(me_)).*(1-(me_)./(Egam_).*((ECrit_)./(Egam_))./(1-(ECrit_)./(Egam_))));
end

MATLAB absolutely will not look at the calling sequence of the function to be called and match up the formal parameter names to find the closest name in the workspace and use that as the parameter. You must explicitly pass all parameters to a function being called.

2 个评论
显示无隐藏无

James Kennedy 2021-1-29

在 MATLAB Online 中打开

Thank you so much for your help. I fixed the function calls to have all the variables in the equations

    syms Egam    
    ECrit = 5;sigmaT = 1;me = 510;
    compton1 = vpaintegral(Gammasigma,Egam,15,30);
    compton2 = vpaintegral(Gammasigma,Egam,11,30);
    compton = compton1/compton2;
    
    function Gs = Gammasigma(Egam,ECrit,sigmaT,me)
    Gs = (exp(-exp(-((log(Egam)+1.2)./(.8)))-((log(Egam)+1.2)./(.8))+1)).*s3(Egam,ECrit,sigmaT,me);
    end
    function sigma3 = s3(Egam,ECrit,sigmaT,me)
    sigma3 = s2(Egam,ECrit,sigmaT,me)+(3.*sigmaT)./(8).*(1)./(((Egam)./(me)).^3).*(1-((Egam)./(me))-(1+2.*((Egam)./(me)))./(1+((Egam)./(me)) ...
        .*(1-(1-(me)./(Egam).*((ECrit)./(Egam))./(1-(ECrit)./(Egam)))))-((Egam)./(me)).*(1-(me)./(Egam).*((ECrit)./(Egam))./(1-(ECrit)./(Egam))));
    end
    function sigma2 = s2(Egam,ECrit,sigmaT,me)
    sigma2 = s1(Egam,ECrit,sigmaT,me)+(3.*sigmaT)./(8).*(1)./(2.*((Egam)./(me))).*((1)./(1+((Egam)./(me)).*(1-(1-(me)./(Egam).*((ECrit)./(Egam)) ...
        ./(1-(ECrit)./(Egam))))).^2-(1)./(1+2.*((Egam)./(me))).^2);
    end
    function sigma1 = s1(Egam,ECrit,sigmaT,me)
    sigma1 = (3.*sigmaT)./(8).*((((Egam)./(me)).^2-2.*((Egam)./(me))-2)./(((Egam)./(me)).^3).*log((1+2.*((Egam)./(me))) ...
        ./(1+((Egam)./(me)).*(1-(1-(me)./(Egam).*((ECrit)./(Egam))./(1-(ECrit)./(Egam)))))));
    end
    

Now I get an error for just the Gammasigma function

Not enough input arguments.
Error in test>Gammasigma (line 8)
    Gs = (exp(-exp(-((log(Egam)+1.2)./(.8)))-((log(Egam)+1.2)./(.8))+1)).*s3(Egam,ECrit,sigmaT,me);
Error in test (line 3)
    compton1 = vpaintegral(Gammasigma,Egam,15,30);

And now I am lost on that too. Egam should be the only variable needed for that function but I still have the 'not enough input' error.