Comparing two matrices, as fast as possible

Question

Altemur Çelikayar 2021-3-12

0
链接

此问题的直接链接

https://ww2.mathworks.cn/matlabcentral/answers/771063-comparing-two-matrices-as-fast-as-possible

评论： Altemur Çelikayar 2021-3-16

Hello Everyone

I am currently writing a music comparing AI code on MATLAB. It is my graduation project.

Firstly, I printed filtered with grayscale 1,0 spectrogram graph of our saved music with the function i write and i recorded 5 second sound. I also processed same way to the sound I recorded from external mic.

SPECTROGRAM OF MUSIC:

5 SECOND RECORDED FILE:

They are both 129xSamples

How can i compare and search from the exact music matrix as fast as possible? I wrote the little function but i cant use with this way. It took apx 56 second and its too long for one song.

Here my little code:

function compare_algorithm(Music1,Sample1)
%Takes data from file
load("datas_audio/"+Music1)
load("datas_audio/"+Sample1)
%Deletes .mat part
Music1 = extractBefore(Music1,".");
Sample1 = extractBefore(Sample1,".");
M1=eval(Music1);
S1=eval(Sample1);
[a,b] = size(M1);
[c,d] = size(S1);
sira = 1;
list1=[];
%Comparing row by row until the finish to findout how long will it take
for SS = 1:b-d+1
    count = 0;
    for jj = sira:d+(sira-1)
        for ii = 1:129
            if M1(ii,jj)==S1(ii,jj-sira+1)
                count=count+1;          
            end
        end
    end
    sira=sira+1;
    CC=count/(c*d);
    list1(end+1) = CC;
end
MAX=max(list1)
end

What is the best way to compare two matrices?

I am planning to compare from 100 to 200 music sample as fast as possible. I am open to any recommendations.

Thanks a lot

Altemur :D

7 个评论
显示 5更早的评论隐藏 5更早的评论

Altemur Çelikayar 2021-3-12

@Walter Roberson Unfortunately I ve 4 month :P lol

Walter Roberson 2021-3-12

@Altemur Çelikayar

In that case I recommend that you do not worry as much about using a technique that is "as fast as possible". If you get into "as fast as possible" then your entire approach might have to be rewritten if you swap your SIMM chips into different banks, since that could affect the timing of caches. An approach that takes you 4 years to build and saves 3 nanoseconds per year is a better candidate for "as fast as possible" compared to an approach that only takes you 2 years to build.

请先登录，再进行评论。

请先登录，再回答此问题。

Answer 1

Shubham Rawat 2021-3-16

0
链接

此回答的直接链接

https://ww2.mathworks.cn/matlabcentral/answers/771063-comparing-two-matrices-as-fast-as-possible#answer_649207

在 MATLAB Online 中打开

Hi Altemur,

I have written a code and I had done intersction of both the matrices column wise without using the for loop.

%loading matrices
load('counting_stars.mat');
load('girenfile.mat');
%transposing the matrices so that number of columns should be same.
a = counting_stars';
b = girenfile';
%intersecting both matrices
[c, ia, ib] = intersect(a, b, 'rows');