Help justifying migration of a test solution control GUI from LabVIEW to MATLAB/Simulink?

2 次查看（过去 30 天）

MR Smith 2021-4-8

0
链接

此问题的直接链接

https://ww2.mathworks.cn/matlabcentral/answers/796472-help-justifying-migration-of-a-test-solution-control-gui-from-labview-to-matlab-simulink

编辑： MR Smith 2021-4-8

We are working on a multifunction motor and battery system tester with a technical college partner who has some familiarity with LabVIEW, and some with MATLAB but not with Simulink. An advisor is an old hand with LabVIEW, though getting LabVIEW enabled equipment is more difficult than decades ago, where we can enable or buy just about any needed test equipment to work with MATLAB & Simulink. The student team involved is staying away from making their preference known letting the "grey hairs" make this choice!

Do any of you have other reasons to justify a move to MATLAB & Simulink? Yes we can incrementally migrate functions through a transition, but we are at a point to specify new test kit in a new phase of the project and I need more reasons than ubiquity and broader user base to push the senior advisor to consider MATLAB & Simulink. Target audience is this SE Asia technical team and regional technical college groups as well as international small businesses working in the field.

MATLAB/Simulink Pros vs LabVIEW

broader array of components available with MATLAB/Simulink integration into test system solution
compiler option to generate target code
training available local to development team (both have extensive online training)
higher cost for LabVIEW for deploy to partners

MATLAB/Simulink Cons vs LabVIEW

senior advisor experience and contacts with NI
initial cost MATLAB/Simulink higher (this is up in the air, I believe educational pricing is appropriate for development budget, sr advisor uses commercial pricing)
extended team more familiar with LabVIEW

Thanks for any feedback!